The Bottom Line
Combining quality food and a convenient theater district location, Angus McIndoe offers a pleasant respite from the typically overpriced, underwhelming area offerings.
Pros
- Convenient location
- Comfortable environment with quality food
- Reasonable prices
Cons
- Look elsewhere for formal dining
Description
- Angus McIndoe Address: 258 West 44th Street
- Subways to Angus McIndoe: 1/2/3/9, A/C/E, 7 to Times Square
- Angus McIndoe Cross Streets: Broadway and 8th Avenues
- Angus McIndoe Accepts: All Major Credit Cards
- Angus McIndoe Hours: Kitchen open continuously from noon to midnight daily.
- Angus McIndoe serves breakfast Monday - Friday from 8 a.m. - noon.
- Angus McIndoe Phone: 212-221-9222
- For a relaxed meal, try 8 pm when everyone else is at the theater.
- Let your waiter know which Broadway show you're seeing, and they'll ensure you make it in time.
Guide Review - Angus McIndoe
While sharing a neighborhood with over-priced and underwhelming restaurants in Times Square, Angus McIndoe is worth visiting. The affordable wine list offers many selections under $30, and wine service is informal, meaning we poured it ourselves as the waiter directed. A dozen fresh, briney oysters($16) included both East and West coast varieties. Appetizer highlights included seared blackened tuna($10) and tender, yet crisp fried calamari($9). Chicken with mashed potatoes($17) was suprisingly moist with a slightly spicy marinade. Red curry sauce contrasted the mild monkfish($19)perfectly. Bruleed lemon tartlet($7) had a sharp, freshing flavor. Oatmeal crisp($8) loaded with blueberries and peaches was delicious and generous enough for two.
