1. Home
  2. Travel
  3. New York City Travel

Shake Shack: Restaurant Review

About.com Rating 4.5

By , About.com Guide

The Bottom Line
A signficant step above your typical fast-food joint, everything at the Shake Shack is prepared to order from high-quality ingredients. Reasonable prices and its Madison Square Park location make it a popular choice, creating a long line for a delicious Shack Burger or Concrete on beautiful days.
Pros
  • Delicious hamburgers
  • Thick concretes
  • Outdoor seating
  • Casual, affordable lunch or dinner
Cons
  • Line can be long, especially at lunch
  • Limited number of tables
  • No indoor seating
Description
  • Shake Shack is located in Madison Square Park on the corner of 23rd Street and Madison Ave (Map)
  • Closest subway to Shake Shack: 6 to 23rd Street
  • Shake Shack Phone: 212-889-6600
  • Wine ($6+) and beer ($4-6) is served and can be enjoyed in the Shake Shack's seating area.
  • Shake Shack Payment: Credit Cards, Cash
  • Shake Shack Price: $10 per person
Guide Review - Shake Shack: Restaurant Review
Located in Madison Square Park, the Shake Shack is a great choice if you're looking for a delicious, yet affordable meal, especially on a beautiful day. Waiting in line is part of the ritual of having a meal at the Shake Shack -- unless the weather is dismal (and sometimes, even then) there is almost always a line of customers waiting to order their burgers and hot dogs. The line tends to move quickly, but you should be prepared to wait 15-20 minutes and sometimes even longer. Since all the food is freshly made, it takes another 10-15 minutes for most orders to be completed.

The Shack Burger($4.38) features well-seasoned freshly ground beef, served with cheese, lettuce, tomato and shack sauce. Cheese seems like overkill on the fries($2.08), which are crisp and generously salted. Almost better than having fries with your burger is having a Chicago Dog($2.77) "dragged through the garden" with tasty toppings. Vegetarians will enjoy 'Shroom Burgers($4.15): a fried portobello mushroom, topped with onions, cheese and shack sauce.

To quench your thirst, try the freshly made iced tea($1.38) or lemonade($1.85).

Save room for dessert (or skip right to dessert if you prefer) because you don't want to miss out on the frozen custard($2.54+) or concretes($5.77). Concretes feature toppings (try the Shack Attack or Hop Scotch combinations or create your own) blended with frozen custard. Puppies will appreciate the Pooch-ini($2.54) with frozen custard, peanut butter and a dog biscuit.

User Reviews Write Review
Explore New York City Travel
About.com Special Features

Watch the Ball Drop in Times Square

What to bring and wear if you're attending this world famous celebration. More >

Hot Winter Travel Deals

Check out these tips on finding the best airfare, hotel rates and cruise deals. More >

  1. Home
  2. Travel
  3. New York City Travel
  4. Where To Eat in NYC
  5. New York Dining Directory
  6. A to Z Index
  7. Shake Shack Restaurant Review - Delicious Hamburgers, Hot Dogs and Concretes at the Shake Shack in New York City's Madison Square Park>

©2009 About.com, a part of The New York Times Company.

All rights reserved.