1. Travel
Send to a Friend via Email

Discuss in my forum

10 Great Pre-Theater Restaurants

Our picks for where to eat before you see a Broadway show!

By

If you're seeing a Broadway Show in New York City, you may be wondering where to eat before (or after) the show. These recommendations all offer delicious meals a short walk from Broadway theaters and many offer prix-fixe menus, promising both a transparent price-tag and a timely arrival at the theater.

My advice: I highly recommend making reservations if you want to dine before your show. Depending on how leisurely a meal you like, I suggest making a reservation approximately 2 hours before your show time to ensure you have plenty of time to dine and still get to the theater on time.
More Suggestions: Times Square Restaurants

1. Toloache

Toloache - contemporary Mexican restaurant in the Theater District
Photo courtesy of Toloache.
Toloache serves contemporary Mexican cuisine just a short walk from many Broadway theaters. Their food is fresh and flavorful, with options that will satisfy a variety of tastes, including many interesting ingredients, such as dried grasshoppers and huitlacoche. Tacos and quesadillas are sized for lighter dining, while platos fuertes are more substantial. Lunch is served Monday through Friday, brunch is served on Saturday and Sunday and dinner is served daily. They also have a separate vegetarian menu available.
  • Address: 251 West 50th Street (Broadway/8th)
  • Telephone: 212-581-1818
  • Cuisine: contemporary Mexican
  • Hours: Sun & Mon: 11:30 a.m.-10 p.m.; Tues - Thurs: 11:30 a.m.-11 p.m.; Fri & Sat: 11:30 a.m.-12 a.m.
  • Price Range: tacos/quesadillas: $12-19; entrees: $20-39
  • Website: toloachenyc.com

2. Sushi of Gari 46

Sushi of Gari 46
Photo courtesy of Sushi of Gari 46
Sushi of Gari has expanded from their original Upper East Side location, giving Theater goers the perfect opportunity to enjoy this destination-worthy restaurant. If you truly want to experience what makes Sushi of Gari special, sit at the sushi counter and splurge on an omakase meal. Otherwise, to get a taste of what makes their sushi different, try their "special" sushi ($49), which features some of the signature sauces.
  • Address: 347 West 46th Street (8th/9th)
  • Telephone: 212-957-0046
  • Cuisine: sushi
  • Meals: Lunch: Monday-Friday: Dinner: Daily
  • Price Range: sushi entrees: $29+
  • Website: http://www.sushiofgari.com/46.html

3. Danji

I'll start with the bad news: Danji is very popular and doesn't take reservations for groups smaller than 6, so you'll have to arrive early and be prepared to wait if you want to dine before your show. That said, their small plates of Korean cuisine (both traditional and modern interpretations) are outstanding. Garlic honey wings and bulgogi beef sliders were standouts when dining there recently.
  • Address: 346 West 52nd Street (8th/9th)
  • Telephone: 212-586-2880
  • Cuisine: Korean small plates
  • Hours: Lunch: Mon-Fri 12-2:30 p.m.; Dinner: 5:15 pm - Midnight (1 a.m. on Fri & Sat)
  • Price Range: small plates: $10-18
  • Website: www.danjinyc.com

4. Sushi Zen

Sushi Zen serves up the neighborhood's best sushi, in a serene setting. Fish is impeccably fresh and reflects both traditional and creative preparations. Sushi Zen also offers several tasting menus ($55-75).

  • Address: 108 West 44th Street (6th/Broadway)
  • Telephone: 212-302-0707
  • Cuisine: Japanese/Sushi
  • Hours: Mon-Fri noon - 2:45 pm; Mon-Sat 5:30 - 10 pm (5 p.m. Sat), closed Sunday
  • Price Range: entrees $25-80+

5. Thalia

Thalia - contemporary American restaurant in Manhattan's Theater District
Photo courtesy of Thalia. Used with permission.
Fresh, creative American cuisine, including a raw bar, is the focus at this stylish theater district restaurant.
  • Address: 828 Eighth Avenue (50th St)
  • Telephone: 212-399-4444
  • Cuisine: contemporary American
  • Hours: lunch Mon-Fri 12-2:30 pm; brunch Sat/Sun 11:30-3 pm; dinner Mon 5:30 - 11:30 pm; Wed-Fri 5:30 - 12 am; Tues/Sat 5 pm-12 am; Sun 4:30-11:30 pm
  • Price Range: prix-fixe lunch $16.95; prix-fixe dinner $35 ($49 w/wine pairing), a la carte available
  • Good for Groups? Yes (private rooms available)
  • Website: www.restaurantthalia.com

6. Osteria Al Doge

Fans of Osteria al Doge appreciate the high-quality cuisine served up at moderate prices at this theater district restaurant. The menu features a variety of pizzas, pastas and main courses that will satisfy those seeking Italian cuisine.
  • Address: 142 West 44th street (7th/Broadway)
  • Telephone: 212-944-3643
  • Cuisine: Italian/Venetian
  • Hours: lunch and dinner daily
  • Price Range: entrees/pizzas $16-32
  • Good for Groups? Yes

7. Lattanzi

The only downside of pre-theater dining at Lattanzi is missing out on the outstanding Jewish-Roman menu that's only available after 8 p.m. once the theater-goers have left. Pastas, grilled meats, fried artichokes and the housemade napoleon are all highly recommended.
  • Address: 361 West 46th St (8th/9th Aves)
  • Telephone: 212-315-0980
  • Cuisine: Italian/Roman/Jewish
  • Hours: Lunch: 11:30 a.m.–2:30 p.m.; Dinner: 4:30 p.m.–11:30 p.m.
  • Price Range: approx $40-50 per person

8. Trattoria Trecolori

Classic Italian cuisine is served with rustic flair at Trattoria Trecolori and you might end up leaving surprised at how affordable it is. Pastas (particularly black linguini) and housemade desserts (including tiramisu) are especially delicious.
  • Address: 254 West 47th Street (Broadway/8th)
  • Telephone: 212-997-4540
  • Cuisine: Italian
  • Hours: lunch and dinner daily
  • Price Range: most dishes $12-28 (specials tend to be higher)
  • Good for Kids/Groups? Yes (private parties also available)

9. FireBird

FireBird offers a beautiful setting and impeccable service for experiencing fine Russian cuisine. Borscht and caviar are highly recommended, as is their selection of vodkas.
  • Address: 365 West 46th St (8th/9th Aves)
  • Telephone: 212-586-0244
  • Cuisine: Russian
  • Hours: Lunch: Mon-Sat 11:45-2:30 p.m.; Dinner: Mon/Tues & Sun 5-9 p.m. Wed-Sat 5–11 p.m.
  • Price Range: lunch prix-fixe $20; dinner prix-fixe $44.98; (a la carte also available)

10. Angus McIndoe

Angus McIndoe offers great service, a pleasant atmosphere and strives to accommodate theater-goers and ensure you'll arrive at your show on time. Excellent raw bar offerings and delicious mains will please traditional and adventurous diners alike.
  • Address: 258 West 44th St (Broadway/8th Ave)
  • Telephone: 212-221-9222
  • Cuisine: American
  • Hours: Mon/Tues 12–11 p.m.; Wed/Thurs 12–11:30 p.m.; Fri/Sat noon-midnight; Sun 12–10:30 p.m.
  • Price Range: entrees $17-28 (porterhouse for 2, $79)
  • Good for Kids/Groups? Yes (private parties available)
Related Video
Best Restaurants on Manhattan Side of Brooklyn Bridge
Walking Tour of Radio City

©2014 About.com. All rights reserved.